Justice Centre Ranks Worst Charter Rights Violators Among Provinces

By Harley Sims April 18, 2022

The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (JCCF) is recognizing the fortieth anniversary of the Charter of Rights of Freedoms by ranking the provinces that violated it worst during the COVID-19 pandemic.

“April 17, 2022, marks 40 years since the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms became a part of Canada’s Constitution,” said JCCF president John Carpay. “But this date has been marred by the long list of serious Charter infringements perpetrated against Canadians by the federal and provincial governments over the last two years.”

The JCCF has been on the front lines of the fight against government and institutional pandemic restrictions, including on the ground in Ottawa during the Freedom Convoy.

Its new report, titled “Who had the worst bunk in Canada’s locked down barracks?,” gives Quebec bottom honours as the worst trespasser on Charter rights, with Prairie province Saskatchewan – the first to drop restrictions – coming in as the “least worst.”

The report notes that whereas the provinces all began with more or less the same restrictions in March 2020, time and differing understandings of “the science” created a wider disparity of responses to the pandemic. As a result, Carpay noted, “some Canadians suffered much more than others.”

1. Quebec

According to the report, Quebec during COVID was “easily the worst offender of freedoms guaranteed by the Charter and the worst place to live in Canada.”

“With its totalitarian-style nightly curfews, inter-provincial travel restrictions, restrictions on travel within the province, threats of a tax on the unvaccinated, disregard for religious freedom, an imposition of vaccine passports for places of worship, and the continuation of mandatory mask-wearing, Quebec earns the top spot as the worst offender of the Charter,” Carpay said.

Quebec also banned Canadians without COVID shots from accessing groceries when it brought in an order requiring proof of vaccination to enter big box stores. The ban caused ads to appear online by those offering to go shopping in stores the unvaccinated could no longer enter.

As the JCCF notes, the mandates are not yet over in Quebec either. The province is also launching a campaign promoting fourth boosters against the “sixth wave.”

2. British Columbia

Despite its formerly libertarian reputation, B.C. came in as second-worst violator, not only for its continuing vaccine mandates against healthcare workers in both the public and private sectors but also for its seemingly arbitrary closure of houses of worship.

“For example, British Columbia ordered houses of worship to be closed, and they were closed for 14 months,” the study reports. “All provinces placed some kind of limitation upon religious observance of course, but B.C.’s blanket, lengthy, all-purpose closure was a unique interpretation of the supposed science behind Canada’s Covid response.”

B.C. was the last province to announce its timeframe for lifting COVID restrictions and also the last to lift its vaccine passport. Last Christmas, provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry came in at number one in True North’s “top 10 worst and weirdest winter COVID restrictions” when she ordered that unvaccinated people would not be allowed to gather over the holidays.

3. Manitoba

People outside of Canada’s easternmost Prairie province might have missed it, but Manitoba was an early and zealous advocate of harsh lockdown measures.

“Manitoba comes close to B.C. in the rank-ordering for second-worst abuser of Charter rights,” the report reads. “Like B.C., Manitoba seriously infringed both religious freedom and mobility rights, closing all houses of worship from November 2020 to February 2021, and again in May of 2021… it joined Ontario and Quebec in mutually closing its provincial borders to supposedly “non-essential” travel.”

“It was also in Manitoba that People’s Party Leader Max Bernier was arrested and charged under Manitoba’s Public Health Act for assembling in a gathering at an outdoor public place and for failing to self -isolate upon entering Manitoba.”

4. Ontario

According to the JCCF, Canada’s largest and most populous province came in somewhere near the middle of the mob. Ontario shut schools the longest and also closed its borders. As the province of the Freedom Convoy and Ambassador Bridge border demonstrations, it also highlighted emergency measures and legislation enacted to shut down pandemic protests.

“Lengthy provincial stay-at-home orders, intended by Premier Doug Ford to be enforced with random police stops, showed an alarming government comfort with Soviet-style enforcement,” the report stated.

“Ontario’s mutual border closures with Manitoba and Quebec also violated Canadians’ Charter right to move. The province prosecuted and fined some pastors and congregations which defied public health orders, but unlike Alberta, at least did not jail anyone.”

5. Atlantic “Bubble” Maritime Provinces

While each Atlantic province offered its own potential examples of Charter and even human rights violations during COVID – including New Brunswick allowing grocery stores to ban unvaccinated Canadians – the JCCF grouped them into a single unit due to their collectively closed border.

“The four Atlantic provinces (Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and

Newfoundland and Labrador) established the so-called Atlantic Bubble,” the report read. “Within this bubble, residents were permitted to move freely.”

“However, other Canadians were barred from entering these four provinces unless government determined the reason to be ‘essential.’ The RCMP set up roadblocks on the Trans-Canada Highway to enforce the exclusion. One could hardly imagine a more unambiguous violation of the Charter section 6 mobility rights to move freely within Canada.”

6. Alberta

The second province to lift COVID restrictions, Alberta came out ahead of others in most respects. Alberta was also the first province to (partially) rescind a vaccine mandate for healthcare workers, although the order still applies to new hires.

The JCCF also noted, however, that it was the only jurisdiction to jail pastors who defied public health orders.

“Pastors (Jim) Coates and (Tim) Stephens were both charged with exceeding capacity limits,” the report recounts. “Pastor Coates spent a month in jail, while Pastor Stephens served three days before the Alberta Crown took the position that his arrest was ‘unlawful.’ Pastor (Artur) Pawlowski had been arrested before for holding religious services without following public health rules, and in October 2021 was fined $23,000 and handed 18 months probation.”

“Operating under (Alberta Health Services) instructions, police padlocked their churches and arrested the pastors. All were jailed. Pastor Coates was held for more than a month, much of this time in solitary confinement with only one other cell mate, and very limited times outside of his cell. He was also fined $1,500.”

7. Saskatchewan

Saskatchewan premier Scott Moe was the first to announce he would be lifting COVID restrictions back in early February. As the JCCF notes, Saskatchewan was also less committed to lockdowns even though its policies echoed other regions. As such, Carpay deemed the Land of Open Skies the “least-bad ‘bunk’ in the locked down ‘barracks.’”

“All-in-all, it appears that Saskatchewan’s violations of Charter rights and freedoms were the least severe in Canada,” the report concludes.

“If true, this is no cause for Saskatchewan or its people to celebrate, because in every Canadian province the ‘two weeks to flatten the curve’ became two years to flatten our freedoms.”